This month, The Man Files brings you Jessica Pauline — a writer and feminist with experience working in some of the dicey-er Los Angeles strip clubs. Lots of ink has been spilled on the sex worker debates. Are women oppressed by sex work? Liberated? Both? How is trafficking distinct from, say, dancing one’s way through law school? In this entry, Jessica leaves those debates for another day and instead turns a keen eye to her observations of the men who make it rain. (—verb: to throw wads of cash in the air for dancers to retrieve as tips.)
Like Jane Goodall and her chimps, I spent a good deal of time during my tenure as a stripper in some of L.A.’s seediest nightclubs observing the behavior of the primates. Not the dancers, mind you — the men who came to watch them.
Based on my humble observations, I came to discover that certain behaviors are both predictable and categorical, and that most hetero men, when confronted with a pair of boobs in a semi-public setting, fall into a few choice archetypes.
Let’s start with what I imagine to be the most common breed of American strip club patron: white, middle-aged men who golf and vote Republican. They swagger in to the club with an air of ownership, their masculinity stuffed into their wallets and tucked neatly into their pressed khaki pants. Observing the dancers with the same level of detached interest that one might imagine they’d use in selecting a prime rib-eye, they pick a girl, begin to talk to her in their most sensual voice while rubbing her back and her leg, and shortly thereafter are ushered back to the VIP room with very little to-do. This is the kind of easy sell around which strip clubs were designed, and for that reason, we’ll call this breed Strip Club Men (SCM).
Now, strip clubs have been around long enough for a type of strip club rebellion to brew amongst men. So imagine, if you will, if the SCM had a son. This son desires nothing more than to be the antithesis to his stuffy, conservative father, and so he becomes sensitive, wears ironic t-shirts to demonstrate the fact that he doesn’t take himself too seriously, and quite possibly sports artistic, sentimental facial hair. Let’s call this breed Feminist Men (FM).
When forced into a strip club, maybe because of a bachelor party, or maybe in search of a place to talk quietly on a Tuesday night, the FM immediately seeks to set himself apart. Rather than sexualize the dancers, he opens with a nice conversation, carefully keeping his eyes above the neck. But as the FM gets less and less guarded, a strange thing begins to happen. He becomes more willing to let his eyes wander down. His friendly conversation becomes more imbued with sexual innuendo. And finally, often after spending copious amounts of money on what he has come to believe is a “real connection,†he tries to get the dancer to go on a date with him. (This, as an aside, is both insulting and never going to happen.)
The final subcategory of men falls deeper into FM territory, and warrants mention simply because of the unique validation that they seek. They’re easy to recognize, because no sooner does some indie chick start swaying her hips to Tom Waits, the King of Melancholy himself, then the Tom Waits Man (TWM) begins nodding in recognition. Before long, he’s dug a crumpled dollar bill out of his pocket and walked up to the stage where he will deposit it, but not until he’s made sure that the dancer sees him so he can compliment her taste to her face and thereby secure his place as profound, mysterious and, of course, different.
Maybe you’ll read this and think that I oversimplify. But since the most honest interaction in sex work is based on a respectful, fun partaking of the service provided, it can’t hurt for men to examine their own behavior with at least as much gusto as I examined it (don’t worry, I took some long, hard looks at myself, too). Without that, gentlemen, you are really just entertainment.
Jessica Pauline is a freelance writer in Los Angeles. An NYU graduate with a degree in music, her writing appears regularly on LAist.com, and has appeared in $pread Magazine, The Printed Blog, the Ventura County Star, and a number of other websites and local papers. She is currently working on a book about her experiences as a feminist stripper, and lives in Silver Lake with her fiance and their dog, Molly.
Comments
Starchild — August 14, 2009
As a sex worker/activist, I have to say that the kind of attitude toward the clients by whom you earn your living -- comparing them to monkeys, playing the superior part of anthropologist with them -- is part of what gives our profession a bad name.
If someone wants to go out on a date with you, that's not an insult! Have the grace and good manners to take it as a compliment. If the feeling isn't mutual, gently decline. You never know, that guy could be the one who happens to stop you from getting mugged outside the club, or who finds and goes to the trouble to return the license, credit card, or other important item you dropped out of your purse.
Or maybe he will never have a direct interaction with you; maybe he just happens to be a person who's going to make an important scientific contribution that benefits humanity. Maybe he's someone who is so lonely and desperate that he's on the brink of committing suicide, and your being nice or not could make the difference. Or maybe he's just an ordinary, hard-working regular joe who's never really had a lot of fun or joy in his life, maybe not rich or attractive enough to find a good-looking girlfriend, and is just unlucky(?) enough to be cursed with the male gene that makes him lust after beautiful women, a desire that will rarely if ever be satisfied?
Is it so much to ask that you be a role model by treating and regarding him with decency and respect?
jessica pauline — August 17, 2009
Thanks for your comment, Starchild. I appreciate your point of view, and would like to start by addressing some of your points.
First, I think you are sorely mistaken (not to mention disrespectful) by disparaging my "attitude." I most certainly do not give our profession a bad name. No one "gives" our profession a bad name. People who dislike what we do dislike it all on their own, based on pre-existing values and beliefs. In fact, I challenge you to find someone who disapproves of sex work solely because of the way a sex worker views her clients.
Also, I retain the right to interpret and respond to clients asking me out on a date in my own way. In my opinion, just because I'm engaged in this line of work does not make it any more appropriate for a client to ask me out on a date as it would be if I were providing any other kind of service. Men who ask sex workers out on dates blur the line between fantasy and reality, and that makes me very uncomfortable.
Saying that I should be complimented by something like that is a very dangerous precedent to set, one in which the interaction takes place completely on the customer's misguided terms. And, the feeling would very rarely be "mutual" -- I'm there to work, not to fall in love.
Moving on. I understand that there is a camp within sex work that views the profession as more of a healing profession. That camp dictates that it's part of our job to get to know our clients more personally, and to understand and "treat" the more profound, personal reasons that they may have for seeking out our services.
I don't necessarily fall into that camp. I view the work as more of a business, one in which I dance and make small talk, and that's about it. If I choose to go deeper with a client, that would be my decision, and made on a case-by-case basis.
Now, that's not to say that I harbor any judgment about the way you conduct business. If you feel it's important to know why clients have sought your services, and more about who they are, I completely respect that. We are, of course, independent contractors and we all work differently. But I stand firmly by the way that I conduct business. It's how I naturally operate, it's how I feel comfortable, and it's been very lucrative for me.
Finally, this piece was intended to be lighthearted and observational. So please don't misinterpret what I'm saying -- I don't dislike strip club clients. But as far as that goes, I have every right to observe them just as they observe me.
urbanartiste — August 21, 2009
I like how you reversed the objectification. God forbid we question the male psyche or behavior in a strip-club.
Casey — August 22, 2009
"Men who ask sex workers out on dates blur the line between fantasy and reality, and that makes me very uncomfortable."
^Well said. It is completely inappropriate behavior, making it obvious the customer doesn't appreciate the JOB of exotic entertainment. It puts dancers "on the spot" and sadly it's an issue that customers are too often in denial about. Their feelings get hurt when forced to face up to the fact that we're being so friendly and engaging because we're being paid. They don't want to believe that, even as they're paying for it, so they conveniently, just don't.
And when they don't respect that inherent, vital boundary, they're not respecting the women working in this business. They're allowing themselves to believe we're truly interested in them, feel this special "connection" with them, solely because believing that makes them feel good. When they act on that fantasy as if it's a reality, they disregard the true reality - that of the complex (and private) personality of the individual woman behind the dancer persona.
It's self-seeking, self-centered, selfish behavior, and very offensive to most dancers, like myself.
Great article Jessica. And picture too - wow, gorgeous.
jessica pauline — August 23, 2009
Thanks Casey! I agree -- asking us out on dates is not something we should take lightly or jsut brush to the side. If customers can't understand the transaction that they're taking part in, they should take a hard look at exactly what it is that they need and want from us, and what we, in reality, are there to provide.
Saxbeat — August 24, 2009
Great article, but since the comments seem to be focused on the dating aspect, I'd like to add one note: You seem to assume a man is asking you out because you are a "sex worker," but there are also men who ask you out despite that fact! There are a lot of men who will ask out pretty much any woman, anywhere. They don't necessarily disrespect these women (even though the behavior may be disrespectful), but they feel that if they are attracted to a woman, there is nothing wrong with asking her out wherever they meet her. These men don't go to a club to meet possible dates, but if after a few minutes of chat, they feel there is an attraction, they may ask the woman out.
However, I can see your perspective on it being an insult, especially if it seems to come out of nowhere. (I can also see Starchild's perspective that it's a compliment... The same is true of wolf whistles from construction workers, but I don't think that means it's a good thing!)
In my life of going to strip clubs, I've met and chatted with hundreds of dancers. I've asked one out in the club. She said no, and that was that. I didn't ask her out because she was a dancer, but because she was the type of woman I would have asked out almost no matter where I met her.
BTW, I fit into another archetype you left out: The liberal, left-leaning, would-have-been-a-hippie-but-I-was-born-too-late guy. I go to a club to enjoy naked women, and that is pretty much it. Being in touch with feminist theory, I sometimes feel a little guilty about clubbing, since I'm not sure I buy the "stripping as empowerment" spiel. I never get VIP dances. I don't have delusions that these women like me. I don't grope them. I'm polite and friendly. I try to be as respectful as is possible. I don't (single exception noted) ask dancers out. I spend enough money to not be a cheapskate, but not so much that anyone will confuse me with Daddy Warbucks. I don't waste dancers' time chatting if I don't plan to buy dances, though, when I used to club more often, I was the guy dancers would come and chat with when the club was slow, even knowing I wasn't going to buy (m)any dances.
Or maybe I'm too uncommon to be an archetype?
gwp_admin — August 24, 2009
Saxbeat -- Interesting spin on the issues! Enjoyed reading your thoughtful comment. You clearly get strip-club etiquette *and* feminist theory.
Thanks to everyone, actually, for weighing in with your thoughts and perspectives.
dirtygirl — September 14, 2009
I've never gotten that whole "healing whore" thing that Starchild alludes to. I know a lot of working women see themselves that way, there's an entire movement about the spiritual aspect of sex work and I suppose it's true, but for me, for the ten or so years I worked the Times Square strip joints, it was a job and a lifestyle. My only concern for my customers was really for their wallets.
I could no way have an open heart in that business and survive. After a few years drug and alcohol free I tried going back and almost immediately turned back into someone I didn't like very much. Today, I choose the open heart
edarnold — March 22, 2010
My experience has been similar to saxbeat, I don't judge people by what they do for a living, in my case i am a liar for a living(actor)so i hope others are not judging me that way. In twenty years of clubbing i have given my number to exactly two girls, alot of asked and i have declined, not because of what they do, but because we were just enjoying the work. The two girls who got my number were very special to me. Real connection, but they felt me out over a period of time and realized i was not playing them i am who i am. Since i have to lie all day i enhoy being open honest & real, I can tell the minute someone starts to perform and it makes my skin crawl but i smile becuase i know it is their job. I can't pay someone to be honest that wouldn't be fair but it is really refreshing when they offer it to you. Even the honest ones slip up and start telling stories sometimes, in that case i switch the subject quickly to something fun that i know they enjoy and we are back having fun again. It's hard for the girls who want to be real to be surrounded by jaded co workers and guys who want to get as much for as little as possible. You are probably wondering why i go to SC and basically it is because i love beautiful women the way some people love art. I enjoy watching they way they move similar but each one still individual, I enjoy that as an actor/exhibionist i can empathize with someone who is comfortable enough in their own skin to interact with complete strangers when they are naked. While i realize that the women are being paid and it is not for pleasure, you must realize that most people would be incapable of baring themselves in front of others no matter the money. It takes a special kind of person, I identify with that persona because that his who i am and i appreciate them as complicated people with complicated circumstances. Dealing with people in broad demeaning generalities sacrifices the few who can actually have some meaningful interaction. When a girl finds a guy who appreciates who she is, what she has overcome, what she has accomplished should she toss it aside because her co workers tell her that all men who come to Strip Clubs are pigs? Should a guy reject his instincts when the girl has over time gotten to the point where she has done everything she could possibly do to convince him that she truly cares for him including returning the money he has spent on her? You perpetuate the myths of society that women who work in strip clubs are merely out to take customers for what they can get and the customers doing the same in return , you belittle people because you refuse to see beyond your own experience. I think maybe you should spend a little more time looking inward, i guess it is no secret you would colour me FM