Don’t hate me Potterites, but I would have preferred the Harry Potter series had been instead the Hermione Granger series. Sure, Harry is great and all, but, given that male protagonists still vastly outnumber female ones, I wish J.K. Rowling had chosen to frame her saga around a female character.
Thankfully, many recent popular saga’s do just that. Alas, some of the most popular (ahem, Twilight) have fairly week protagonists a little too focused on romance and not nearly focused enough on charging through complex narratives.
Instead of talking about Edward’s golden eyes a bazillion times, how about some heroines with wit, intelligence, bravery and charisma? For that type of character, my recent favorite is Katniss from The Hunger Games.
This summer, I am on a mission to find another Katniss-fix for my daughter and I (heck, for my mom and son too, who also loved the series). I have thus far turned to Matched, Divergent, and Uglies.
I was disappointed with Cassia’s Matched. The book’s love triangle focus smacked very much of Twilight with similar undertones of pro-abstinence and you-need-a-man-to-be-complete messages.
In contrast, Tris, from Divergent, gave me the Katniss chutzpah and Hermione intellect I yearn for rolled into one. And, so far, Uglies’ Tally and Shay read like feminist rebels in training.
Sadly, films with strong young female protagonists have proven non-existent this summer. While I loved
Alice in Super 8, I was underwhelmed by the typical damsel-in-distress narrative she ultimately inhabited. Though I commend (and appreiceate) J Boursaw’s coverage of five recent strong females in family films, I would argue that strong female leads are much rarer in film than in YA fiction. While the Goodreads list of “Best Feminist Young Adult Books” started by Jessica Stites of Ms. Magazine swells with 512 titles, movies aimed at the YA set predominantly feature male leads. For a visual of these male-helmed films, take a gander at Margot Magowan’s gallery of 2011 kids movie posters here.
Unfortunately, most Harry Potter posters could be included in this gallery as they feature Harry, not Hermione. I will admit that I have already purchased my midnight tickets of the final Potter film for July 14, but that doesn’t mean I’ve given up on a saga as popular and influential as Rowling’s that features a female at the helm.
Thankfully, The Hunger Games film adaptation is in the works, with the wonderful Jennifer Lawrence (of Winter’s Bone) as the lead. Though I fear Hollywood will up the love triangle quotient of the story and downgrade Katniss’ feminist awesomeness, I am still hoping this saga can finally prove that female-helmed narratives can attract large, diverse audiences and lay that “boys will only read about (or watch films with) male leads” claim to rest.
Ah, if only I had the power to enact an “Imperio” curse and make Hollywood and the book publishing world fill our pages and screens with females of the Hermione/Katniss ilk! Or, maybe a new spell is needed – Arrresto Bella! Hermione Engorgio! – meaning stop with the Bella-esque characters and let narratives swell with Hermione magnificence.
Comments 19
Margot Magowan — July 8, 2011
Thanks for this piece and posting the link to my depressing gallery. Kudos for dealing with Harry Potter. I didn't include the poster even though, as you write, it would completely fit because it breaks my heart.
The Harry Potter series got my seven year old daughter to read 700 page books. And its by a single mom! But why not a girl wizard as the main character? And why does the writer call herself the gender ambiguous J.K.? Maybe she figured, given the total sexism in kidworld, a male hero is the best way to sell books. Maybe she figured she might not get published at all if she wrote 'Hermonie Granger and the Sorcerer's Stone.' If so, given the climate in Hollywood and publishing, maybe she made the right choice for herself as a writer, deciding the world was only ready for the girl to be a sidekick-- but she'd give her a really good part, make her really smart, and not the love interest of the main character.
S.E. Hinton wrote 'The Outsiders' about a boy gang to much acclaim. Maybe in 2011, women writers still exist in the world of George Eliot more than anyone admits.
Margot
Hermione Granger and the Sorcerer’s Stone? « ReelGirl — July 8, 2011
[...] Girlw/Pen Natalie Wilson asks why are strong girls missing from YA books. She wishes Harry’s series [...]
gwp_admin — July 8, 2011
Thanks for your comment Margot.
I recall reading that Rowling claims that Harry was fully formed as the main character in her vision of the series and that she never considered a female lead. This speaks to your suggestion that we are still in a "George Eliot world" where authors must use gender ambiguous names and helm their narratives around male leads. Those that don't often appeal mainly to female audiences and get labeled romance or chick-lit. This is one reason I am so enamored by The Hunger Games -- the fandom is females and males even thought the book has a FEMALE lead- something people (from librarians to academics to parents) keep claiming means only females will like it. Hoping Divergent can prove the same and speak to a diverse fandom and prove that females are just as appealing and fully human as males as protagonists!
Margot Magowan — July 8, 2011
Natalie,
I need to read The Hunger Games, it sounds great. Would my seven year old like it or too old?
MM
gwp_admin — July 8, 2011
I think it's a bit old for a seven year old as there is quite a bit of graphic violence that is very visceral/bloody.
Deborah Siegel — July 8, 2011
Arrresto Bella! Hermione Engorgio! !!!!!!
Margot Magowan — July 8, 2011
OK, just checked the Ms list. We are not there yet, or Hunger Games as you write. We're strictly in Middle Grade, just out of picture books. If you've come across any great MG lists, let me know.
MM
Fi — July 9, 2011
What about Sookie Stackhouse?
(in the books, not the weak damsel they make her out to be in the tv show)
She's a strong female character who can take care of herself, and although she is sometimes a damsel, she saves men as much, if not more, than they save her. Maybe not a series for the youngsters, but I would encourage anyone to give it to their teenage daughters.
gwp_admin — July 9, 2011
Margot,
I don't know of any lists, but I remember my daughter liked the Franny K. Stein series at that age. Of course the Ramona books are an option too. I will ask my daughter for more ideas when she is home from her summer trip!
Fi,
Yes, I love Sookie, but I don't consider that series YA. As for being appropriate for teenagers, I would note the series is oozing with sex and would only recommend it for teens who have someone to talk with about the way the saga represents sexuality or who are attune with issues of female sexuality, agency, etc. Sookie is quite the sex fiend and isn't condemned for it -- which I like - but then the series also leans towards heternormativity and has a few too many strong/violent men to make me recommend it wholeheartedly.
Claire — July 14, 2011
Julie Bertagana -- Exodus, Zenith and Aurora -- also postapoaclyptic with a female protagonist and Patrick Cave, Sharp North and The Selected - similar vein as The Hunger Games, with a different twist (and written before!)
Will the New Hermione Please Stand Up? : Ms Magazine Blog — July 14, 2011
[...] Cross-posted from Girl w/Pen [...]
Kathie — July 19, 2011
Don't know if you've seen this column yet, "In praise of Joanne Rowling's Hermione Granger series"
http://globalcomment.com/2011/in-praise-of-hermione-granger-series/
Shelley — July 19, 2011
All the alternate (and superior) Hermiones are in Jane Austen....
What if you’ve got Hermione fever? (A Hermione Granger link round up…) « Professor, What If…? — July 19, 2011
[...] Popularizing Strong Girls: Will the New Hermione Please Stand Up? [...]
Brooke — July 25, 2011
I must say I agree with Margot. Maybe our world isn't quite ready for a female role, and maybe J.K. Rowling knew she'd sell more books by making Harry, Harry. But what a great character Hermione is! Everyone knows Harry would be nowhere without his female friend, and I also appreciate that she was not the main characters love interest. Maybe Hermione will help boys appreciate the heroine and realize that its ok to read books about girls. Maybe soon they will be reading books about girls who aren't just killing people like in "The Hunger Games."
Damian Trasler — July 25, 2011
In JK's defence, I believe I read that she was advised to use JK to avoid people who might be prejudiced by a female writer, though I think that idea is ludicrous. But don't rail on her for choosing Harry. As a writer myself, I can tell you that more often than not, it's the character who decides who they're going to be. JK herself said that she "saw" Harry while taking a train journey, and that image of a boy on his way to school was what led to the story. I love the fact that it's viewed as perfectly normal now for Harry and Ron to have a best friend who's a girl, and a girl who is smart, and brave, and not just eye candy. She more than pulls her weight in the story.
I was also blown away by "The Hunger Games" and immediately handed it to Mrs Dim, who also loved it. I hope they do the books justice in the films.
fgfh — March 8, 2012
You and your daughter should take a peak at Gunnerkrigg Court (www.gunnerkrigg.com). It's an ongoing webcomic (although it's currently novel-sized in length!) that features 2 strong female protagonists who solve scientific and magical mysteries in a hauntingly beautiful Hogwarts-ish setting.
Griffin — October 14, 2012
I don't know if you've happened across Frances Hardinge's "Fly By Night" but it's got one of my favorite female leads of recent reading. The world is like the quirky fantasy version of "1984" where books and reading have been outlawed by the state so they don't stir up trouble by giving people differing ideas of "right" and "truth." Our heroine, Mosca, has been taught to read by her radical historian father and takes off for the big city with Saracen, her homicidal goose and conman Eponymous Clent. It's a book made for reading out loud because Hardinge has a great deal of fun with language, but what really stands out about it for me is that it's a big idea book. I love that Mosca ends up wrestling with stuff like who has the authority to decide what's right, and with whether a safe life with what you need is better than a dangerous life with adventure and uncertainty. Content-wise, it's a big book and fits the reading level for Harry Potter fans but it's not overly violent, and pretty much skips over romance in favor of highwaymen, powerful duchesses with deadly creatures, and the complicated politics of the fractured realm.
Griffin — October 14, 2012
Sorry for the double posting but I thought I'd also mention my most favorite webcomic too: "Girl Genius" (http://girlgeniusonline.com/) which is about the last of a famous (and mostly evil) family of mad scientists. The Girl Genius of the title, Agatha, is an incredible inventor but she sensible as well as smart. She's very much in the drivers' seat of her own destiny which is something that makes me very happy.