This week there’s a heated thread running through the Park Slope Parents listserv about the appropriateness of reprimanding other people’s misbehaved kids in public spaces. The thread hits a nerve, because I definitely used to be that cranky person who scowled silently when other people’s children ran reckless in a crowded restaurant or played freeze tag in the checkout line. And then something changed. My twins were born. Since their arrival, that wave of annoyance that wells up when somebody else’s child whoops it up at the very moment I crave peace has not exactly subsided, but it’s transformed. Now, instead, I get curious. I project: What will my children be like when they’re that age?
Until I had my own, I was never a kid person. I hated babysitting. I was raised sibling-free. I grew into a grown up who often found kids who weren’t related to me bothersome. In my twenties, I knew (hoped?) that I’d want a kid of my own one day, but only vaguely, the same way I thought it might be nice to have a puppy. Rarely did I think concretely about what it might be like to be pregnant, or raise a child, or be someone’s mother. There were times in recent years when I actually wondered if the ubiquitous maternal instinct would kick in when my time came, or whether it would pass me over. I knew that if I had kids I’d love them. But would I love being their mother?
As part of a generation raised to view the so-called phenomenon of abandoning hard won careers for full-time motherhood with a healthy dose of skepticism, my unease about whether motherhood would suit me also meshed with fear. Coming to late motherhood in the shadow of all those dread media stories about women opting out, part of me feared motherhood for its very lure. I wouldn’t be able to quit working once I had a child, due to financial necessity, but I wondered if I would wish I could.
Now that the twins are here (4 months old next week!), and I’m engaged in compelling work with like-minded collaborators–some of whom are themselves similarly struggling to make work fit with motherhood as well as the other way around–I’m not so worried about being tempted to abandon my other life’s work. It’s not merely financial. It’s core.
And as for my proclivity to scowl at other people’s children, and my worrying whether maternal instinct would kick in? While I don’t think I’d call this instinct, my maternal lens has come into focus since my babies arrived. To wit: On a snowy day like the one we had this week, my Brooklyn neighborhood is a cornucopia of cuteness. Kids stuffed into snowsuits slide by our apartment window, pulled by their parents on toboggans on their way to the park. Must be something about the coziness of winter and all those teeny mittens. I pass a child on the icy sidewalk holding his father’s hand and flash forward to the day when my son and my daughter will be walking by my side, each of their mittened hands holding one of my own.
Comments
Renee Siegel — February 12, 2010
Debbie, there is no doubt that you love being Teo and Anya's mother; all one has to do is to see you with them!! Proves that it is not a requirement to gush over other people's children before one has their own!! Regarding disciplining other people's kids, I often have the impulse to try to discipline the parents of the misbehaved child. Often it is the parent who provokes the child by either saying something that humiliates the child or demands that the child understand adult things when the child is too young. Children respond to frustration with behavior; they cannot always understand the long sentences and lectures that parents offer. The child child gets upset and then acts up. From the observer's point, one needs to be empathic with both the child and the mother or father.
Perhaps that is what you are trying to describe, Debbie, when you say ..."something has transformed..." in you. I know you will continue to enjoy Teo and Anya and you will know when to interrupt their disruptive behavior with positive suggestions and/or actions. And, if you get stuck, Marco will know what to do!!! Renee
Elline — February 12, 2010
D, Beautifully put and wonderful to read! So glad to hear your story as it evolves.
Lori — February 14, 2010
Hi Debbie. Your thoughtful post really takes me back....to when my boys were babies. But your remarks about taking mental notes when in the company of parents with older kids ("what will it be like when my kids are that age someday?) still hit home. Now, it happens when I am with friends who have teenagers; even though Benji and Eli are 11 and 8 years old, I still have a hard time conceiving what they will be like 4 or 5 years from now. Parenting is never static--or at leat not static for long--as our kids (and we) are constantly evolving.
Rebecca — February 16, 2010
Debbie-
I also have always wondered what Zoe and Jessica would be like when they are older, as Lori says, at every age. It's a game that sometimes leaves me wondering if I'm fully appreciating them at the age they are (but I must be, right?). I am lucky that my children are fairly well behaved in public, and I often have to bite my tongue in the presence of misbehaving children (and their parents, yes!). Unless they put my children at risk, I just keep it to myself (until later, when I ask Z&J what they thought of the misbehaving kids).
Adina — February 17, 2010
Really appreciate your post and the points you make about how our our own lived experiences transform our perceptions of the world around us. For me, becoming a mom was the most life-changing event, and, as you point out, our lives are not just changed at our child's birth/adoption, but parenthood continues to change our lives, our views, our feelings as we go about our daily lives.
Deborah Siegel — February 23, 2010
Thank you, Adina, Rebec, Lori, Elline, and Renee (aka Mom) for these comments. I love being in dialogue about this with all of you! xoD