Much as I want to think of myself as a feminist parent, sometimes I doubt my credentials. After all, I don’t forbid Hannah Montana for my daughter or swordplay for my son even though both of these activities certainly do reinforce gender stereotypes (although I should probably add that my daughter took jui-jitsu for a time and my son happily watches Hannah Montana).
But I know that when it comes to discussions of loving relationships, this is one area where my feminism comes through loud and clear. With the current setbacks—like yesterday’s California High Court ruling in support of the gay marriage ban and victories over gay marriage, I see this as an important social justice issue. After all, I want my daughter and my son to grow up in a culture that will recognize and equally value their loving relationships whoever their partner may be.
Katy Perry as “Compulsory Heterosexuality 101â€
My 8-year-old daughter loves Katy Perry’s “I Kissed a Girl.†She’s especially familiar with the chorus, which goes like this:
I kissed a girl and I liked it
The taste of her cherry chapstick
I kissed a girl just to try it
I hope my boyfriend don’t mind it
It felt so wrong
It felt so right
Recently after the song played my daughter asked, “Why is she worried about what her boyfriend will think?â€Â I explained that the song was about two girls kissing. Perhaps not surprisingly, she had been listening to the song and singing the words without really understanding it. When I explained the idea of two girls kissing, some predictable “ew’s†and “yuck’s†ensued (the standard grade school reaction to all romantic kissing). I also explained that some people think two girls or two boys kissing is a bad thing.
I went on to tell her what I thought—that two people who love each other can kiss, whether they are two girls, two boys, or a boy and a girl. I talked about the way that “gay†can be used as an epithet, and how in my view such a usage was inappropriate.
My daughter wanted to try the idea on for size. What would be the difference between using gay in a “mean†way and in a “nice†way, she wanted to know? She thought out loud, “I could say, ‘You’re gay, hooray!â€
I loved this response. Tolerance is one thing: plenty of research suggests that young people are more supportive of gay marriage than their older counterparts. But celebration is another, and my daughter is right there already. Dismantling heterosexism and homophobia are important parts of this mix as well: my daughter may not be there yet, but that’s where my feminist parenting comes in, and we’ll take it day by day.
While I don’t think Katy Perry’s “I Kissed a Girl†lyrics are especially feminist—heterosexual male enjoyment of “lesbian†sexuality has been around for a long time, it opened a great window of conversation and analysis for our family. Now that’s feminist, so thanks, Katy Perry.
GWP, readers how does feminism influence your parenting? I’d love to hear your stories.
Comments 4
Scenes from a Chinese Restaurant: Why Equality Is the Future « Kittywampus — May 28, 2009
[...] Perhaps more crucially, our kids are growing up in a changing society where it’s just normal to know same-sex couples. They have a lesbian aunt. In the Bear’s grade level at his school, there are two families each headed by two women. It seems bizarre to kids that some of their friends’ parents aren’t allowed to get married. My kids aren’t oddities; I think they’re part of a growing norm that’ll embrace all sexualities and all family forms. [...]
Sungold — May 28, 2009
Allison, I saw this just after I put up a post of my own on how *normal* it is for kids to think same-sex couples are just, well, other kids' parents. In other words - normal! My older son, who's 9, was just outraged when he figured out what had happened with Prop 8. He has a strong sense of fairness, and so Prop 8 just makes no sense to him.
Allison Kimmich — May 28, 2009
I absolutely agree with you both. My son's preschool classmate had two moms, and he found it completely unremarkable.
And yes, I wish that our kids' sense of fairness would inspire more of our adult counterparts!
Ramiro Brodka — January 28, 2011
Great article! nvofgfjv