I just published a piece in a special issue of American Behavioral Scientist on the topic of Prosumption and the Prosumer. The article will likely be of interest to many of Cyborgology blog readers. In it, I consider the applicability of Marx’s two main critiques of capitalism—alienation and exploitation—to social media. Though Marx was describing the materialist paradigm of factory production, it is useful to see how far these concepts can be stretched to account for the immaterial paradigm of digital prosumption, because, even if we observe weaknesses in how the concepts graft on to social media, these observations become a starting point for new kinds of theorizing.
Additionally, I found it important to try to bring alienation into the conversation surrounding social media. Thus far, most Marxian analysis has focused solely on exploitation (many hyperbolically claiming that we have entered an era of hyper- or over-exploitation). I argue that exploitation has remained a constant between material and immaterial modes of production and that what is most remarkable is the fact that productivity occurs on social media with so little alienation.
You can access the article on the publisher’s site or as a .pdf here.
PJ Rey (@pjrey) is a sociologist at the University of Maryland working to describe how social media and other technology reflect and change our culture and the economy.
Comments 6
Will the IPO Change the Way Users See Facebook? » Cyborgology — May 17, 2012
[...] quickly, users should realize that they are being exploited (see: here and here)—i.e., they are creating lots money for Facebook, but that they aren’t seeing a cent of it. [...]
Will the IPO Change the Way Users See Facebook? « PJ Rey's Sociology Blog Feed — May 17, 2012
[...] quickly, users should realize that they are being exploited (see: here and here)—i.e., they are creating lots money for Facebook, but that they aren’t seeing a cent of it. [...]
Will the IPO Change the Way Users See Facebook? » OWNI.eu, News, Augmented — May 24, 2012
[...] quickly, users should realise that they are being exploited (see: here and here)—i.e., they are creating lots money for Facebook, but that they aren’t seeing a cent of it. Of [...]
Business | Colombo Herald — May 29, 2012
[...] quickly, users should realise that they are being exploited (see: here and here)—i.e., they are creating lots money for Facebook, but that they aren’t seeing a cent of it. Of [...]
Alienation, exploitation and social media | Images of Technology Alienation — November 5, 2012
[...] Source: Cyborgology (2012) [...]
Alienation, exploitation and social media | DJG Photography — January 24, 2013
[...] Source: Cyborgology (2012) [...]