A new survey, sponsored by the University of Wisconsin-Madison’s E-Business Institute, reveals students’ preference for “lecture capture,” the technology that records, streams and stores what happens in the classroom for later viewing. There’s more about the study here, with a focus on the financial costs to universities for doing this. I’m skeptical about “lecture capture” technology as a workable solution for delivering useful content in a way that’s financially profitable. Personally, I’m more interested in the bottom-up, DIY-side of what this means in terms of pedagogy and technology. more...
Archive: Sep 2008
According to a recent report at Inside Higher Ed, some colleges are moving to connecting students and faculty via Instant Message. At Ivy Tech Community College, in Indiana, serves more than 115,000 students a year on 23 separate campuses across the state, adopted an instant messaging platform called Pronto, from the collaborative learning software company Wimba. Here’s how Andy Guess describes it in the article:
Like a turbocharged AOL Instant Messenger or Google Talk, it lets students chat online with their professors in text, audio or video form, for virtual office hours or impromptu question-and-answer sessions.
Unlike the free IM clients students are already familiar with, though, the software integrates with existing course management systems, such as Blackboard and Moodle, so that their buddy lists are populated with the classmates already signed up for a specific course. Students also see each other’s real names, with identities that are validated through the system — no “sk8rdude21″ who may or may not be your group partner — and they can save their chats for later consultation.
Several years ago, I experimented with being available to students via Instant Message for “virtual office hours.” It was a new-enough idea at the time that it was sort of thrilling, for them and for me. But, I have to admit, the thrill wore off pretty quickly. In part, that was because of the blending of “public” and “private” personas on the IM client. I may want to share my IM handle with friends, but it’s another thing to be that accessible to students. And, the most frustrating part of me as a professor was that after the semester – and this experiment – ended, all my students were still on my “buddy list” and they continued to contact me via IM long afterward. Perhaps this why I no longer use IM much. Still, I think that a proprietary system that’s directly tied to class rosters, uses people’s real names, and – perhaps most importantly – goes away at the end of a semseter, might have potential for creating a sense of belonging to a campus community. This will be an interesting development in social media to keep an eye on.
I’m generally inclined to agree with Vint Cerf’s twist on the famous anarchist slogan: “Power corrupts. PowerPoint corrupts absolutely.”
Nonetheless, many of us—myself included—end up using slides anyway. Done right, they can be a very good thing.
A fellow Minnesota grad student, Wes Longhofer, has developed a unique style of PowerPointing that really pushes the technology in a fun, creative way. I asked Wes if I could share one of his presentations here, and he said yes: Download the PDF here.
I’ll mostly let the slides speak for themselves, but a few notes:
- This is for an introductory Political Sociology class. As you’ll see, the readings for this class were Domhoff’s Who Rules America?, John Gaventa’s Power and Powerlessness, and Thomas Frank’s “What’s the Matter with Kansas?”1
- All frames within each slide are displayed at once in the PDF, though you can easily picture how the various arrows, highlights and questions on each slide appear one-at-a-time during the presentation. Because of all the crazy fonts & images Wes uses, distributing the original PowerPoint file isn’t really an option.
- There are four movie clips embedded in the presentation (obviously they’re not included in the PDF—you’ll just see a placeholder image). In order, they are:
- A clip from the film “Wag the Dog” about political spin.
- A clip from “Century of Self” on the role of psychoanalysts and the CIA in the overthrow of the Guatemalan government.
- A Reagan campaign ad from 1984.
- An anti-Howard Dean ad from 2004 about “latte-drinking” liberal “freak shows.”
- This particular class meets only once a week in 2.5 hour sessions, in case you were wondering how so much material could possibly be covered in one class.
And Wes puts this kind of care into every lecture he prepares. (Is anyone surprised he won our department’s Outstanding Graduate Instructor Award this year?)
Footnotes
- Of special value to Wes & I as we are both native Kansans. [↩]
As the semester (or trimester) gets under way for most academics in the U.S., faculty are dusting off lectures and preparing their lectures. The “chalk and talk” lecture format is, of course, still popular. Yet increasingly universities are opening up the classroom to those outside the enrolled student population and posting digital videos of faculty lectures online. I’m sure there are more, but here’s a beginning list of resources (from OpenCulture):
Spotlighted Collections
- University of California – Berkeley
- Arguably the most substantive YouTube collection out there. Features a large number of free courses, plus numerous lectures given by important figures.
- Indian Institute of Technology/Indian Institute of Science
- Presented by the leading technology institutes in India, this collection features more than 50 free courses. Obviously has a strong technology/engineering bent.
- MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
- Makes available many of the videos produced as part of MIT’s leading OpenCourseWare initiative.
- Stanford University
- Newly launched, the collection already features a couple hundred videos, including several free courses.
- UChannel (Princeton)
- Spearheaded by Princeton, this collection aggregates quality videos coming from a consortium of major universities.
Other University Collections
- Auburn University
- Hard to separate the intellectual substance from videos that have a more promotional & internal bent. But some of the former is there to be found.
- Berkman Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School
- The videos hosted here look at how the digital world and the law intersect.
- Carnegie Mellon
- Among other things, this collection features the highly popular video: Randy Pausch’s Last Lecture: Achieving Your Childhood Dreams.
- Duke University
- Individual videos explore the research coming out of one of America’s leading universities.
- Duke’s Fuqua School of Business
- Similar to Duke’s main collection, but focused on business.
- EGS (The European Graduate School)
- This European collection features important, contemporary theorists, philosophers, and filmmakers.
- Harvard’s Bok Center
- A small collection focused on pedagogy.
- Old Dominion
- A little bit of a hodgepodge but there’s some interesting items in the mix.
- Ohio State
- So far not an overwhelming use of the medium.
- Oxford University – Saïd Business School
- Rather internally focused. Not much in the way of educational content per se. But let’s keep our fingers crossed that it eventually offers more.
- Purdue University
- Again something of a hodgepodge. Wheat and chaff.
- Sonoma State
- A more intellectually robust collection that features a fair amount of notable lectures.
- The Open University
- The Open University (OU) is the United Kingdom’s only university dedicated to distance learning.
- Tulane University
- You can access some of the speeches by esteemed guest speakers here.
- University of Arizona
- You can sort through a good number of talks here.
- University of California TV
- UCTV pulls together videos from the campuses, national laboratories, and affiliated institutions of the University of California.
- University of Chicago Press
- Though still modest in size, the collection features some interesting items.
- University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill
- The collection is substantive on the whole. You will need to sift through the videos to find ones of interest.
- UCSF Memory & Aging Channel
- UCSF, one of the leading medical schools in the US, features videos that will “educate patients, caregivers and health professionals about the various forms of neurodegenerative diseases.” The diseases covered here include Alzheimer’s, Frontotemporal dementia and Creutzfelt-Jakob
- USC (University of Southern California)
- Vanderbilt University
- An eclectic mix.
This sort of opening up of higher education is, as John Seely Brown points out, part of a larger Open Educational Resources (OER) movement, that began in 2001 when the William and Flora Hewlett and the Andrew W. Mellon foundations jointly funded MIT’s OpenCourseWare (OCW) initiative, which has provided free access to a wide range of courses and other educational materials to anyone who wants to use them. Just another sign that we’re in the midst of a sea change in higher education.
A news item caught my attention about the recent Hurricane Gustav and blogging, including micro-blogging such as Twitter. James Jenaga, writing for the Chicago Tribune, reports this:
The fearful weather reports about Hurricane Gustav did not persuade Sheila Moragas to leave Old Jefferson, a suburb just west of New Orleans. It was the 38-year-old mother’s dwindling ranks of online friends on the micro-blogging network Twitter.
One by one, Twitterers with nicknames like “HumidCity,” “DomesticKitty” and “NOLADawn” pulled up stakes Sunday and left south Louisiana, live-blogging the building drama through text messages on their laptops, home computers and cell phones.
“It’s been helpful,” Moragas said. “It’s less hyperbole, more reliable. There’s also a lot of people panicking, but it’s neighborly. It feels like you’re talking to your next-door neighbors and trying to say, ‘What’s the best thing to do?’ ”
At noon Sunday, Moragas, known as “NOLAnotes” to her followers on Twitter, decided the wisest option was to leave, abandoning the New Orleans area in advance of a massive hurricane for the second time in three years.
This story makes me wonder how differently disasters such as Heat Wave, and the pattern of humans coping with disasters, might be in the future.
According to a recent report at Inside Higher Ed, some colleges are moving to connecting students and faculty via Instant Message. At Ivy Tech Community College, in Indiana, serves more than 115,000 students a year on 23 separate campuses across the state, adopted an instant messaging platform called Pronto, from the collaborative learning software company Wimba. Here’s how Andy Guess describes it in the article:
Like a turbocharged AOL Instant Messenger or Google Talk, it lets students chat online with their professors in text, audio or video form, for virtual office hours or impromptu question-and-answer sessions.
Unlike the free IM clients students are already familiar with, though, the software integrates with existing course management systems, such as Blackboard and Moodle, so that their buddy lists are populated with the classmates already signed up for a specific course. Students also see each other’s real names, with identities that are validated through the system — no “sk8rdude21″ who may or may not be your group partner — and they can save their chats for later consultation.
Several years ago, I experimented with being available to students via Instant Message for “virtual office hours.” It was a new-enough idea at the time that it was sort of thrilling, for them and for me. But, I have to admit, the thrill wore off pretty quickly. In part, that was because of the blending of “public” and “private” personas on the IM client. I may want to share my IM handle with friends, but it’s another thing to be that accessible to students. And, the most frustrating part of me as a professor was that after the semester – and this experiment – ended, all my students were still on my “buddy list” and they continued to contact me via IM long afterward. Perhaps this why I no longer use IM much. Still, I think that a proprietary system that’s directly tied to class rosters, uses people’s real names, and – perhaps most importantly – goes away at the end of a semseter, might have potential for creating a sense of belonging to a campus community. This will be an interesting development in social media to keep an eye on.
I’m generally inclined to agree with Vint Cerf’s twist on the famous anarchist slogan: “Power corrupts. PowerPoint corrupts absolutely.”
Nonetheless, many of us—myself included—end up using slides anyway. Done right, they can be a very good thing.
A fellow Minnesota grad student, Wes Longhofer, has developed a unique style of PowerPointing that really pushes the technology in a fun, creative way. I asked Wes if I could share one of his presentations here, and he said yes: Download the PDF here.
I’ll mostly let the slides speak for themselves, but a few notes:
- This is for an introductory Political Sociology class. As you’ll see, the readings for this class were Domhoff’s Who Rules America?, John Gaventa’s Power and Powerlessness, and Thomas Frank’s “What’s the Matter with Kansas?”1
- All frames within each slide are displayed at once in the PDF, though you can easily picture how the various arrows, highlights and questions on each slide appear one-at-a-time during the presentation. Because of all the crazy fonts & images Wes uses, distributing the original PowerPoint file isn’t really an option.
- There are four movie clips embedded in the presentation (obviously they’re not included in the PDF—you’ll just see a placeholder image). In order, they are:
- A clip from the film “Wag the Dog” about political spin.
- A clip from “Century of Self” on the role of psychoanalysts and the CIA in the overthrow of the Guatemalan government.
- A Reagan campaign ad from 1984.
- An anti-Howard Dean ad from 2004 about “latte-drinking” liberal “freak shows.”
- This particular class meets only once a week in 2.5 hour sessions, in case you were wondering how so much material could possibly be covered in one class.
And Wes puts this kind of care into every lecture he prepares. (Is anyone surprised he won our department’s Outstanding Graduate Instructor Award this year?)
Footnotes
- Of special value to Wes & I as we are both native Kansans. [↩]
As the semester (or trimester) gets under way for most academics in the U.S., faculty are dusting off lectures and preparing their lectures. The “chalk and talk” lecture format is, of course, still popular. Yet increasingly universities are opening up the classroom to those outside the enrolled student population and posting digital videos of faculty lectures online. I’m sure there are more, but here’s a beginning list of resources (from OpenCulture):
Spotlighted Collections
- University of California – Berkeley
- Arguably the most substantive YouTube collection out there. Features a large number of free courses, plus numerous lectures given by important figures.
- Indian Institute of Technology/Indian Institute of Science
- Presented by the leading technology institutes in India, this collection features more than 50 free courses. Obviously has a strong technology/engineering bent.
- MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)
- Makes available many of the videos produced as part of MIT’s leading OpenCourseWare initiative.
- Stanford University
- Newly launched, the collection already features a couple hundred videos, including several free courses.
- UChannel (Princeton)
- Spearheaded by Princeton, this collection aggregates quality videos coming from a consortium of major universities.
Other University Collections
- Auburn University
- Hard to separate the intellectual substance from videos that have a more promotional & internal bent. But some of the former is there to be found.
- Berkman Center for Internet and Society at Harvard Law School
- The videos hosted here look at how the digital world and the law intersect.
- Carnegie Mellon
- Among other things, this collection features the highly popular video: Randy Pausch’s Last Lecture: Achieving Your Childhood Dreams.
- Duke University
- Individual videos explore the research coming out of one of America’s leading universities.
- Duke’s Fuqua School of Business
- Similar to Duke’s main collection, but focused on business.
- EGS (The European Graduate School)
- This European collection features important, contemporary theorists, philosophers, and filmmakers.
- Harvard’s Bok Center
- A small collection focused on pedagogy.
- Old Dominion
- A little bit of a hodgepodge but there’s some interesting items in the mix.
- Ohio State
- So far not an overwhelming use of the medium.
- Oxford University – Saïd Business School
- Rather internally focused. Not much in the way of educational content per se. But let’s keep our fingers crossed that it eventually offers more.
- Purdue University
- Again something of a hodgepodge. Wheat and chaff.
- Sonoma State
- A more intellectually robust collection that features a fair amount of notable lectures.
- The Open University
- The Open University (OU) is the United Kingdom’s only university dedicated to distance learning.
- Tulane University
- You can access some of the speeches by esteemed guest speakers here.
- University of Arizona
- You can sort through a good number of talks here.
- University of California TV
- UCTV pulls together videos from the campuses, national laboratories, and affiliated institutions of the University of California.
- University of Chicago Press
- Though still modest in size, the collection features some interesting items.
- University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill
- The collection is substantive on the whole. You will need to sift through the videos to find ones of interest.
- UCSF Memory & Aging Channel
- UCSF, one of the leading medical schools in the US, features videos that will “educate patients, caregivers and health professionals about the various forms of neurodegenerative diseases.” The diseases covered here include Alzheimer’s, Frontotemporal dementia and Creutzfelt-Jakob
- USC (University of Southern California)
- Vanderbilt University
- An eclectic mix.
This sort of opening up of higher education is, as John Seely Brown points out, part of a larger Open Educational Resources (OER) movement, that began in 2001 when the William and Flora Hewlett and the Andrew W. Mellon foundations jointly funded MIT’s OpenCourseWare (OCW) initiative, which has provided free access to a wide range of courses and other educational materials to anyone who wants to use them. Just another sign that we’re in the midst of a sea change in higher education.
A news item caught my attention about the recent Hurricane Gustav and blogging, including micro-blogging such as Twitter. James Jenaga, writing for the Chicago Tribune, reports this:
The fearful weather reports about Hurricane Gustav did not persuade Sheila Moragas to leave Old Jefferson, a suburb just west of New Orleans. It was the 38-year-old mother’s dwindling ranks of online friends on the micro-blogging network Twitter.
One by one, Twitterers with nicknames like “HumidCity,” “DomesticKitty” and “NOLADawn” pulled up stakes Sunday and left south Louisiana, live-blogging the building drama through text messages on their laptops, home computers and cell phones.
“It’s been helpful,” Moragas said. “It’s less hyperbole, more reliable. There’s also a lot of people panicking, but it’s neighborly. It feels like you’re talking to your next-door neighbors and trying to say, ‘What’s the best thing to do?’ ”
At noon Sunday, Moragas, known as “NOLAnotes” to her followers on Twitter, decided the wisest option was to leave, abandoning the New Orleans area in advance of a massive hurricane for the second time in three years.
This story makes me wonder how differently disasters such as Heat Wave, and the pattern of humans coping with disasters, might be in the future.