In her provocative book, The Technology of Orgasm, Rachel Maines discusses a classic medical treatment for the historical diagnosis of “hysteria”: orgasm administered by a physician.
Maines explains that manual stimulation of the clitoris was, for some time, a matter-of-fact part of medical treatment and a routine source of revenue for doctors. By the 19th century, people understood that it was an orgasm, but they argued that it was “nothing sexual.” It couldn’t “be anything sexual,” Maines explains, “because there’s no penetration and, so, no sex.”
So, what ended this practice? Maines argues that it was the appearance of the vibrator in early pornographic movies in the 1920s. At which point, she says, doctors “drop it like a hot rock.” Meanwhile, vibrators become household appliances, allowing women to treat their “hysteria” at home. It wasn’t dropped from diagnostic manuals until 1957.
Listen to it straight from Maines in the following 7 minutes from Big Think:
Bonus: Freud was bad at this treatment, so he had to come up with some other cause of hysteria. After all, she says, “this was the guy who didn’t know what women wanted.” No surprise there, she jokes.
Cross-posted at Pacific Standard.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 12
Mr. S — November 20, 2014
Sounds like a great argument for legalized prostitution.
Daily Feminist Cheat Sheet — November 20, 2014
[…] Why did doctors stop giving women orgasms? […]
sallyedelstein — November 20, 2014
The female orgasm has been a favorite topic of medial scrutiny over the decades. According to the mid century medical community an epidemic was ravishing the nation...frigidity- American women were supposedly as frosty and frigid as the polar vortex. With misogynist misinformation running rampant the cold war was a chilly time to be a woman.Was the cold war woman's libido really in the deep freeze? http://wp.me/p2qifI-25C
James McRitchie — November 20, 2014
I'm glad I majored in sociology. Always interesting at Sociological Images.
Schnizzle » Daily Feminist Cheat Sheet — November 20, 2014
[…] Why did doctors stop giving women orgasms? […]
hithere — November 21, 2014
There were a lot of fucked up practices against women, but especially mentally ill women, in the past. Learned much about it in my psych courses.
northierthanthou.com — November 24, 2014
The image of physicians dropping vibrators will probably be with me for a couple weeks now.
fairyhedgehog — November 27, 2014
I think this has been generally discredited. In the absence of evidence for the practice you have to rely on deduction and basically the Victorians were very anti-masturbation, doctors had nurses in with them even to administer anaesthetics, they knew what a clitoris was (because one doctor was removing them), and vibrators did not appear in Victorian porn. So pretty much there's no evidence for the theory but it's titillating so it's become a factoid, much like "We only use 10% of our brain).
I couldn't find scholarly papers on the subject. This one: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3480686/ only traces the history of "hysteria" as a disease but doesn't focus on treatment.
These non-scholarly articles raise interesting points: http://www.lesleyahall.net/factoids.htm#hysteria
http://tropicsofmeta.wordpress.com/2013/02/20/the-contested-space-of-the-victorian-vagina-the-myth-of-vibrators-and-hysteria-therapy/
Episode 69: The Haunting (1963) | The Whorer — December 1, 2014
[…] “Why Did Doctors Stop Giving Women Orgasms?” […]
Medusa Jordan — December 17, 2014
The film Hysteria supposedly is based on an actual doctors practice. It is all rather silly and salacious, but it did happen in London, at least.
Need? I’ll tell you what I need……I need you to get lost! | arts and humanities……….. — September 17, 2015
[…] Between ‘erotic melancholy’ and ‘hysteria’ the treatment of the so-called medical problems of women show a long history of quack and confounding treatments that will literally curl your hair. Have a read here. […]