“But what would you put on the door?!” said a facility manager at an airport, his concern echoed by an administrator at a university: “When people are looking for a restroom, they look for the ‘man or woman’ icon. It’s what we know to look for that means restroom.”
We can’t have gender neutral bathrooms, you see, because there’s no symbol for it… or is there?
This is the symbol used at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs. Sam Killermann, the social justice activist at which the above statements were aimed, doesn’t prefer it. “Even if you’re familiar with gender identity and diversity,” he writes, “the literal interpretation of this image (a half “man” half “woman”) is a disconcerting representation of ‘gender neutral.’”
So, what is there to do? Killermann has an innovative solution. “I had this breakthrough moment,” he says, “where I was like, ‘If I was urgently in need of a toilet, what visual cue that a room contained a toilet could I use?'”
Tada!
“It’s really not that hard.”
Killermann wants us to replace all the man and woman signs on one-person, private public restrooms with this one — or with the British-inspired W.C., which he has decided stands for “who cares.” Print yours here.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 41
Samuel Killermann — July 1, 2014
I like your summary, Lisa. Thanks for spreading the word :)
Bill R — July 1, 2014
Maybe add a sink and a mirror to touch it up a bit but you're on the right track IF we all need to go to gender neutral bathrooms in public places.
I for one hope we don't and I believe the majority of both men and women are with me on this.
I suppose the lone exception would be for very small establishments without room for 2, but is it that hard to bow to the differences between us, at least for purpose of defecation?
Are there actually advocates who spend time and money arguing for this?
Larry Charles Wilson — July 1, 2014
When I lived in Korea in the late 1960s public restrooms, especially in restaurants, were coed. Despite being an American, I quickly adjusted.
Pamela Oliver — July 1, 2014
I was in a restaurant somewhere in Europe (thinking it must have been Spain, maybe Barcelona?) where the bathrooms were six unisex rooms with locking doors, all lined up in a row. Seemed really rational.
StacyMcKenna — July 1, 2014
What's wrong with:
http://besttrophiesandawards.com/shop/blue-or-black-ada-family-restroom-sign-18-thick-raised-white-text-graphics/
crackerme_crackermenot — July 1, 2014
gender-neutral for one person bathrooms is not the issue! the issue is that gender-neutral does not work for multiple person restrooms!
Jhoosier — July 1, 2014
This also works: http://www.clker.com/cliparts/2/b/7/2/1206572119215038269johnny_automatic_NPS_map_pictographs_part_68.svg.med.png
I mean, the image of the toilet in the post is not always what a toilet looks like. Here in Japan, a symbol similar to that one is used inside gendered restrooms to denote the western-style toilet, and a symbol that almost looks like a bedroom slipper is used to denote the Japanese-style one.
Allison Stover — July 2, 2014
I feel that all bathrooms should become unisex period. stalls give occupants privacy. now if you are thinking what woman wants to see a wall of urinals in the bathroom?, don't forget men can urinate in a toilet just as well as have a bowel movement. the real issue here is that society socializes people to feel insecure about themselves and other people. and the media portrays Trans* and Gender Non conforming people to be evil sexual predators, which can not be further from the truth. Does a plastic sign really protect anyone? no... all it does is give people an excuse to discriminate against men and women. in some cases it causes bodily harm because trans* people are afraid to use the bathroom all day so they will go without food and water all day in order to avoid needing the restroom and hold it all day if they end up needing it anyway.
If you're going to claim that women are cleaner than men, that is a stereotype. i have been in both men's and women's restrooms and they both can be spotlessly clean (college) or disgustingly dirty (Gas station).
Valeria — July 2, 2014
I was in Budapest, recently. When my flight landed, I looked for a bathroom. That's the sign I found: "standard" bathrooms, simply named mosdók ("toilets"), for men -
Andrew — July 2, 2014
While "WC" is language-specific, it's prevalent in quite a lot of countries, especially in Europe and the Middle East, and widely understood in all but one English-speaking country.
Like the Metric system, it's a pretty global thing that Americans have stubbornly resisted for reasons unknown to me.
lem — July 2, 2014
it works for multi person washrooms too - if the room's got toilets, use the toilet icon, if it also has urinals, add a urinal icon
mimimur — July 2, 2014
The problem here is that toilets only look exactly like that in the US. In many parts of the world, they're even holes in the ground.
Chad White — July 2, 2014
I love the toilet icon. However, it seems a partial substitute for engendered signage. The issue: bathrooms that contain urinals. Should these be differentiated? If so, is a urinal a good alternative icon?
Perhaps. Part of the bathroom choice typically represented with engendered bathroom signage goes beyond gender performance or physical comfort. Part of it also has to do with bathroom utility (sit/stand) and expectations of cleanliness (splatter). So, signs might well indicate whether the bathroom is for sitting or standing, perhaps including a person sitting or standing next to or on the toilet. That seems graphic (no pun intended), but it would offer a more detailed, gender-neutral message about what is intended.
jules — July 2, 2014
no, no, I like the ladies room. I feel awkward when i want to just take a minute and theres a man next to ye (at the sink). Also when you enter the toilet at the same time, no.
Dan — July 2, 2014
There's a restaurant at the MoMA in New York with a unisex bathroom. Just a large room with a dozen or so stalls. The walls and doors of the stalls run from the floor to the ceiling, so you don't feel exposed at all. It was a little odd the first time I used it, seeing a woman come out of the stall right next to me, but it didn't take long to get used to it.
jf — July 2, 2014
At my work we have two single toilet bathrooms, one labeled for men and one for women. The bathrooms are identical (no urinal in the men's room). I use the men's room all the time, I don't see any point in waiting for for ladies room when there is another toilet available. It seems stupid to me that they have gender labels since they are exactly the same.
In Sweden I once saw a unisex bathroom, it had individual stalls but the walls for each one went all the way down to the floor so you couldn't see feet or hear noises. I felt very comfortable with that (I am really creeped out by using public restrooms at the same time as other people).
Hanna — July 3, 2014
Some time ago I came across a page on the web that focused on designing the bathroom sign in a neutral yet informative way, but I can't for the life of me find it anymore. It's final versions of the sign followed a system where the toilet was depicted from the front and added elements provided additional information, like whether there was armrests, a changing table, the width of the stall (I clearly remember the visible brick wall on each side of the toilet for this one) etc. They even included braille. It was very thorough and much more deserving of being called "innovative" than this design.
Yay? – Bridget Magnus and the World as Seen from 4'11" — July 3, 2014
[…] here; free science books; birth control Supreme Court Hobby Lobby ruling follow up links; problem solved!; media points out what many of us have been saying for years; apparently I’m the only one […]
July 4th Sex Links! | Sex with Timaree — July 4, 2014
[…] the problem of signage on a gender neutral bathroom door. Steel dresses play with masculinity and […]
a humble servant — November 22, 2015
Design another sign for restroom with urinals. Then you can just make the existing restrooms gender neutral. Let people decide for themselves which one they want to use. Don't knock urinals they work well and save water and time. If designing new, put urinals beyond stalls. You could also put a window in restroom door to promote safety. As long as you can't see urinals from outside door there is no reason not to. Actually there are female urinals, but I don't think they would go over well in the u.s. something to consider though.