Yikes. In a report designed to prove the feasibility of measuring electrodermal activity on subjects going about their daily life, at least one student showed near brain-death during class.
Am I exaggerating? Yes. But, even so, brain patterns during class matched watching TV closer than any other activity on the list. Studying and homework, lab work, and socializing got more of his attention… sleep was a veritable mental work-out compared to class.
Draw whatever conclusions you will…
Joi Ito, via BoingBoing. Full text of the paper here.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 17
Cheirogaleidae — May 1, 2012
Note: it's not "at least one," it's the ONLY student they tested long-term in situ.
GrumpyMrGruff — May 1, 2012
I only skimmed it, but it looks like the EDA (electro-dermal activity) they were measuring was from a wearable wrist sensor, not an EEG of brain activity.
Elena — May 1, 2012
The student also "flatlines" when they've been watching TV (see days 4 and 7) and relaxing (days 3 and 7). So my working hypotheses is that the "flatline" thing isn't really a "flatline".
hopeless shade — May 1, 2012
I had a much beloved professor who would lecture with two humming slide projectors, a completely dark room, and a monotone voice. It was impressively soporific, and unhelped by the fact that he would only have class around 3pm.
So, all I can say to this student is, I know your pain, have enough cash for an extra coffee, and remember that you'll never be asked about the Raphael readings because he'll spend the whole quarter on da Vinci.
Marcel Estemonte — May 1, 2012
Title is misleading (I would even go as far as to call it sensationalist). As someone already pointed out, this study is NOT measuring brain activity.
Hadrian — May 3, 2012
Electrodermal activity is also knows as Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) and is used to measure stress and arousal, not brain activity. Think Lie Detector, not brain state.
Concerned Professor — May 3, 2012
Lisa -
Let me start by apologizing for the tone of the following post. I realize it's antagonistic, but I'm not sure how else to present this....
Please be responsible in your posts to this blog. Over and over again, I have students who bring "information" from this website to class. Unfortunately, it's come to the point where I have now asked them to stop reading this blog.
You're doing a grave disservice to the discipline of sociology by framing these posts as in any way connected to the discipline. As other have already commented, there are a number of issues (all of which have not been listed yet) with both the presentation of your "data" and the claims that you make.
While there are MANY problems with this particular post, one of the most glaring is that you are presenting data from a sample of one. This is the exact mode of thought that sociology professors battle in introductory and lower-level classes. It's disappointing to see you implying conclusions and generalizations from a sample of one when we spend a great deal of energy trying to show our students that this is not how sociology operates as a discipline.
This is not the first post to this blog that has been problematic. I've seen a number of other posts that received rather critical comments regarding the claims that you make and the (lack of) data to support those claims.
Undergraduate students read these posts. Please do not misrepresent our discipline by framing these as sociological insights. You are completely entitled to your own opinion and reading of social issues. My issue is not with the position you take on things, but the fact that you present these opinions and sensationalized writings as sociologically informed.
a neuroscientist — May 4, 2012
As others have said, galvanic skin response (GSR) is ONLY a measure of sympathetic arousal (i.e., a state of acute stress) and has nothing to do with brain activity. Mental arithmetic and the Stroop task produced changes in GSR only because they stressed people performing them. I guarantee that if this student had been surprised by a question during class, there would be a significant change from baseline in the GSR record.
The device itself is pretty interesting, though.
brain death « Zombies in the Academy — May 6, 2012
[...] Lisa Wade @ Sociological Images and Joi Ito, & Boing Boing. Students brains flatlining during classes Like this:LikeBe the [...]
10 #longreads for this week — in great company — May 20, 2012
[...] studies show student brains flat-lining during class. Eeek. // The Society Pages If I talk to a friend and they keep asking me for information I know they already have, I have a [...]
DIGEST – 20 May | sam whiteman — September 9, 2012
[...] studies show student brains flat-lining during class. Eeek. // The Society Pages If I talk to a friend and they keep asking me for information I know they already have, I have a [...]
William Byrd — August 18, 2023
Looking for essay inspiration? Your favorite shows on Netflix can be a great source of ideas for your next work. In-depth tips and examples await you on the blog at https://writersperhour.com/blog/netflix-shows-essay-writing-inspiration . Pick the best moments from your favorite shows and use them in your writing.