Amid accusations of racism, the European Union (EU) has withdrawn a two-minute video designed to raise awareness about “Neighbourhood Policy,” an approach to establishing “deeper relations” with neighboring state the need for unity among EU nations and acceptance of candidate states hoping to enter. In the video, sent to us by Claire P., the EU is personified by a white woman, who is facing attacks from all sides.
Bruno Waterfield, writing for the Telegraph, describes the scene:
First the EU heroine… is menaced by a Chinese Kung Fu master. Then a second threat appears as a urbaned practitioner of Kalaripayattu, a southern Indian martial art, levitates towards her brandishing a scimitar.
As she turns to face the new menace, a third black assailant with dreadlocks cartwheels aggressively towards her before striking a Capoeira pose, the Brazilian martial art.
Here’s screenshots of all of them, but for the full effect, you’ve got to watch (if just for the music and sound effects):
At this point, the woman takes a deep breath, multiples to represent the many states in the EU, and models peaceful behavior that her would-be attackers adopt.
The EU is expressing surprise that a video featuring a peaceful white person and violent, dangerous dark-skinned people might be considered racist. They have released a classic non-apology that privileges intent over impact, denies that the clip was actually racist (it has just been “perceived” so), and identifies the main problem as other people (who got all hypersensitive and “felt offended”):
The clip was absolutely not intended to be racist and we obviously regret that it has been perceived in this way. We apologise to anyone who may have felt offended. Given these controversies, we have decided to stop the campaign immediately and to withdraw the video.
UPDATE: Reader Katrin says the video was about increasing integration and cooperation of states and the European Commission’s enlargement policy, not about the “neighborhood” policy as reported by the Telegraph:,
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.It was for greater unity of existing EU member states (which is why the video is entitled “Growing Together”) and candidates for membership (which is why it says “the more we are the stronger we are”) in order to show a united front to the rising powers China, India and Brazil. It was intended to portray that if the EU acts united, then China, India and Brazil will be willing to engage with the EU constructively…Current candidates of accession are e.g. Iceland, Macedonia, Montenegro, Turkey and Serbia. Enlargement and unity as a tool for greater power when facing rising economies was the intended message of the clip, not the ENP.
Comments 46
Tuli — March 13, 2012
this crap was really paid for by the EU? I couldn't believe it when I saw it first... But it's pretty revealing how they are thinking, perceiving themselfs: Those uncivilized savages have to be made peaceful by us.
Antonio Santo — March 13, 2012
By "they" you mean politicians, Tuli? 'Cos european people (like me) don´t perceive ourselves as supperior to anyone...
pduggie — March 13, 2012
Isn't the whole idea of a European Union racist? if you tried to form a "European pride" club on campus, everyone would know you were just starting a crypto-white-pride club.
pduggie — March 13, 2012
is the secret message that if Europeans would breed more, the demographic bomb of massive numbers of Chinese, Africans, and Indians would be contained? Or is the secret message that if we would include those three within the EU better, we'd be stronger (EU growing by adding those three).
Since the video has multiplying white women containing the latter, i guess its the former, though if its supposed to illustrate the "neighborhood policy" (as I understand it) I guess its the former.
They could have been more crypo racist if they'd cast Europe as the goddess europa or something
Guest — March 13, 2012
Not to mention the dynamic of a rational thinking, enlightened white woman teaching her ways to a group of "savage" dark-skinned men. It's also interesting that this advert represents these three men as ahistorical, embodiments of "ancient" forms of martial arts, rather than portraying them as more modern-day threats (terrorists). Well done, EU, well done.
Jess — March 13, 2012
It's like she made a little roda for the capoerista!
Taavet Ropp — March 13, 2012
Wouldn't having white actors stand in for the rising superpowers (that is, China, India and Brazil, respectively) have been more contentious? Also, if the offensive part is derived from the smashy-fighty to peaceful transition... the whole being hip part of paying overt homage to Tarantino would've fallen flat.
I'd say it's those knee-jerk reactions that drive EU media campaigns to their bureaucratic mediocrity.
Pastas — March 13, 2012
I could not believe my eyes. The tolerant EU has trolled it self
Anonymous — March 13, 2012
This is humiliating. The worst part is how hollow the unity of the stars look when considering that the enemies here are othered and constructed as threatening because of cultural attributes, while the EU in itself is ridiculously diverse in culture and at least one potential member (Turkey) could easily be lumped with the othered threats in a western narrative. Basically they're boasting about their moral superiority by bullying their own.
Anonymous — March 13, 2012
Wow, I was primed by the post, but the video still made my jaw drop! The level of cluelessness (which is a charitable word to apply here) on display has to be seen to be believed. Other posters have already mentioned the anachronistic and stereotyped depiction of people from other lands here, but also this whole dynamic of people depicted as dangerous and savage ganging up on the shores of Europe, threatening Europe's purity and innocence, but then ultimately being overcome by Europe's superiority -- this more or less could be white supremacist propaganda, although to be fair I doubt it was intended as such.
Fernando — March 13, 2012
Maybe the characters representing the "invading" nations were intentionally portrayed in those ridiculous ways, the message being that people from those places aren't the caricatures they were shown to be but rather European citizens like any other.
So it would be about people who immigrate to Europe and get their citizenship or that are descendants of people who have recently gone to Europe. At least that's what I understood from it, in which case it is bad but not as bad because the stereotypes have a point.
However it still implies that Europeans need to be the ones to take the first step in being civil else the invaders will just be violent. Well yeah, I guess it was actually pretty bad.
Flikr — March 14, 2012
The part where they just DISAPPEAR was the most shocking to me. Also, why are they seriously implying India, Brazil, and China pose a physical threat to Europe?
I'm also really wondering what the specific purpose of this advertisement is.
Monchichili — March 14, 2012
After establishing a repressive immigration policy by setting up Frontex, "external relations" and detention centres, they feel secure enough to think that no one would be offended by this!?
If the women isn´t a metaphor for fortress Europe, what else is it!? I absolutely cannot believe that the people who made this add wouldn´t know what they were playing at - you don´t get to do something like without observing the political background. There would be at least one person of authority to subscribe this and I that´s what I find highly disturbing
Guest — March 14, 2012
God, the ad was trully bad, but what's even worse is the amount of self-righteous holier-than-thou outraged people posting here, usually using lots and lots of long and complicated words to feel like they're part of some kind of intellectual avant-garde.
I mean, it's not as if ethnical and cultural stereotypes were not commonly used in commercials, books, movies... pretty much all around the world.
When Indiana Jones shots a frigging Indian weilding a saber and doing some fancy martial art, it's fun. When a woman convinces the same saber-weilding dude to sit and talk, it's "tasteless", "racist", "humiliating" and what not. Get a gripe people.
Or maybe they could have portrayed the Indian with a clone of Lakshmi Mittal. He's wearing suits and all, but he's still a douche. And the Chinese could have been your average corrupted local tyrant, the one who kidnaps farmers to enslave them in some factory, and make 15 year old kids work in toxic environment, with the governement blessing? They could like, attack the white woman with dollars and bonds and their suitcases, or even gang on her during a monopoly game. How cool would that be, seriously?
guest — March 14, 2012
Love the "Kill Bill" style outfit, too. The more "we" are? "We" who? White people?
guest — March 14, 2012
Love the "Kill Bill" style outfit, too. The more "we" are? "We" who? White people?
Elena — March 14, 2012
The EU is expressing surprise that a video featuring a peaceful white
person and violent, dangerous dark-skinned people might be considered
racist.
What, the entire population of the 27 countries *at once*? Ô_ó And nobody in the EU is criticizing this campaign?
When you mean the apparatchik in charge of talking to the press for one particular directorate in the European Commission, please say that. Don't slander the greater part of a continent.
Ash — March 15, 2012
Okay seriously even if someone wanted to rationalize this by saying "well she personifies the EU because most of the members are fairer skinned and most of the current enemies are closer to these colors/cultures" or whatever, they could have just as easily done something with stick figures or animated androgynous tan-skinned (think: south park episode from the future where everyone has breed with one another so everyone is the same average skin tone) wearing t-shirts with the flag and the EU character passing the t-shirts out and then a nice handshake and cup of tea sharing, clinking of glasses, showing the one giant EU turn into each individual nation and they do various things indicative of their culture (bier, kielbasa, dirndl, I know little about other fun cultural things so insert something fun here) and they all have a nice little party while showing that the EU is all about spreading peace in the face of adversity. And said adversity shouldn't be people of color specifically, it should just be random "adversaries" that look like the averaged tanish EU person and go from there. Yeah. There's my idea.
Neil — March 15, 2012
It's not technically racists but it's certainly idiot and panders to base emotional elements. Plus if you're trying to emphasis unity amongst neighbours you're better off not implying they're all warmongering tyrants. Else that lady should actually be a Christian Crusader. What I find most offensive are the millions of Euro blown on this utter waste of time and the EU bureaucrats patting themselves on the back for a job well done.
amanda crow — March 15, 2012
Obviously not racist. Racism only exists in the US.
The EU’s on a roll with first racist, then sexist ads « Uphill — June 22, 2012
[...] Images has a good post about that [...]