Last week I posted about the stereotype that Black people love watermelons, explaining that it originated with efforts to justify slavery. Black people were simple, slavery proponents argued, so a delicious watermelon was enough to make them happy.
This stereotype, long past its strategic usefulness, nonetheless persists. Barack Obama’s election to the U.S. presidency, for example, inspired a rash of watermelon-themed commentary, including this one:
(source)
In light of this history, as well as the ongoing racism, the product below — a Valentine’s Day candy that pairs two Disney princesses — is rather, let’s say, insensitive. The White Cinderella Aurora character decorates the vanilla flavored side; the Black Tiana character decorates the watermelon flavored side. Just… wow.
Thanks to Caroline H. for forwarding this along.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 130
Anonymous — March 4, 2012
I checked the source, but couldn't find any justification for the claim that the stereotype existed prior to the late 1800's. I don't recall any mention of chicken or watermelon in Stowe, but I wasn't looking for it.
What's the earliest primary source for images of blacks with watermelons?
Anonymous — March 4, 2012
Wow, this is simply amazing. The speaks to the lack of diversity in America's boardrooms and places where decisions are made. It's amazing to me that no one caught this or raised an objection. "Which Disney character should represent the watermelon flavor?" - "the black one!"
Elena — March 4, 2012
Is that even Cinderella? She looks more like Aurora/ Sleeping Beauty to me. Anyway, that's terribly off-model for either one. Tasteless flavouring aside, it's rather sad that older characters with their distinctive looks are being homogenized to blandness in the Princesses merch line.
Anonymous — March 4, 2012
My father worked with Max Robinson, the first black national news anchor (he shared the ABC Evening News with Peter Jennings and Frank Reynolds for a time). Once they were out at lunch, and Robinson, looking over menu, mentioned that as it happened, he did really like watermelon, but felt he could never be seen eating it.
Fembot777 — March 4, 2012
And the white, blonde Disney princess has Vanilla flavored, same stereotype just a different color.
Lisa Marie Fairbrother — March 4, 2012
Did anybody ever see them in person? When you google it, the box has four princesses and three flavors. On the cover it shows Belle as vanilla. Do you think they might have mixed up the princesses and the flavors? Meaning that this may just be a random combo.
Steve Pan — March 4, 2012
Hilariously the racial group with the highest per capita consumption of watermelons in the US are Asian Americans. Come summertime, I can't think of any days where I'm not eating some form of watermelon.
LarryW — March 4, 2012
Am I insulting African Americans if I eat watermelon. If an African American eats a watermelon is s/he guilty of reinforcing a stereotype?
Sally Villarreal — March 4, 2012
Nevermind, the problem fixed itself.
Sally Villarreal — March 4, 2012
Nevermind. The problem fixed itself.
Adam Wargacki — March 4, 2012
Matching the black princess up with the watermelon flavor appears to be random. The question is: given that one of the princesses is black and one of the flavors is watermelon, is the racist dog whistle inevitable?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/6-DISNEY-FAIRIES-DIG-N-DIP-CANDY-STICKS-PARTY-FAVORS-/150753166991?_trksid=p3284.m263&_trkparms=algo%3DSIC%26its%3DI%26itu%3DUCI%252BIA%252BUA%252BFICS%252BUFI%26otn%3D21%26pmod%3D390388575834%26ps%3D54#ht_557wt_698
guest — March 5, 2012
Does anyone know when and how 'vanilla' became a synonym for 'boring and bland'? It is a real, authentic flavour in itself, and has an 'exotic' history in Europe; it seems weird to me that it would be considered such a nonentity.
Legolewdite — March 5, 2012
Oh, the Frog Princess. Or Disney comes to the long overdue conclusion that Black people have
money too and would like to be included in some of Disney's default
settings (I'm far too cynical to think they make these decisions in the name of art). In any case I recall it being remarked on many times in the
media that this was a big step for the Mickey Mouse corporation, as it
ushered in its first black princess into their ever burgeoning Princess
product line.
"Green is freedom," the movie says. It sounds a little like the Citizen's united ruling, no? It also echoes
that old statement, Money talks and bullshit walks. And Disney makes it
clear from the beginning of this film that you can't just luck out and
inherit good fortune. Obviously no fairy godmother is just going to
leave you wishes. We are given here a prince who was cut off from his
family's wealth for "being a mooch," and Disney's theme is meant to
resonate with our industrious self-determined spirits. You have to make
you dreams happen, and stop mooching off your magical or royal
relatives.
"You can't just wish upon a star," the movie says.
So isn't
this an awful lot of work-harder-to-get-ahead rhetoric for a film that
marketed itself as breaking down barriers and offering role models for
the first time to an otherwise marginalized majority (one of the song
lyrics even mentions them "living on the margins"). I mean, coming from
a billion dollar corporation that at times has been as synonymous with
America as Coca-cola smacks me as a bit insincere. Disney, with its
immense amount of talent, artistry, and innovation, has helped produce
the culture of exclusion that they're only now trying to address, and
this is what they do? - Abdicate all responsibility for not just
themselves but all institutions by saying you can just get ahead by
working harder?
This pull-yourself-up-by-your-own-bootstraps mentality ignores whole sections of people who've historically been barefoot.
Today in Thoughtlessness: Disney Edition - Jack & Jill Politics — March 5, 2012
[...] Disney Edition 5 Mar 2012 Author: Marcus Toussaint Peeped the pic below over on Gawker (via Sociological Images).Can you believe this ish? After all this character has done for the Disney franchise?HOW ARE THEY [...]
Disney’s Only Black Princess Hawks Watermelon Candy [Racism] | Fashion Clothing Blog — March 5, 2012
[...] vanilla-flavored dipping stick? Yeah, that’s totally a coincidence. Right, guys? Guys? [via Sociological Images] [...]
Christina G. Smith — March 5, 2012
I had honestly never heard of this stereotype before. I wonder if it's more of one that stayed in the south more. If there is a kernel of truth in it I think it can be said of any race. Watermelon is freaking good maybe it was just one of the cheapest things slave owners could give to their slaves, or rather let them have it, and it became a symbol without real reason. I don't think it's still hung onto though by the majority of the population. Look how much watermelon is used in high end restaurants these days.
I'm betting it came down to some person who was given the task of assigning the flavor to a princess and it just happened vanilla seemed logical. She looks like living vanilla. If there had been chocolate as a flavor I bet they would have given it to Tiana. But then they thought, "oh crap that's really racist we need to pick a new flavor." So they picked out watermelon instead. The more people let this stuff go it will fade away as all stereotypes should. At least that's how I feel about it.
hellbrunn — March 5, 2012
That's Sleeping Beauty (Princess Aurora) not Cinderella
blksista — March 5, 2012
Jeeeeez. (SMDH.)
Disney Princess Tiana Appears On Watermelon Candy Package, Is It an Assault or Harmless? | Frugivore Magazine — March 5, 2012
[...] offices would keep a close eye to any similar marketing mishaps. Well they haven’t and Sociological Images obtained a picture of Disney’s princess-themed Valentine’s day candy that pairs Sleeping [...]
For Discussion: Disney Uses Its Only Black Princess To Sell Watermelon Candy… Racist, Or Racistly Delicious? | :: Sparxxrx LLC :: — March 5, 2012
[...] Source [...]
First Black Disney Princess Endorses Delicious Watermelon Candy, Stereotypes « keepmefromdatingarepublican — March 5, 2012
[...] to Sociological Images, the most offensive thing about Dig N’ Dips candy isn’t the fact that it aims to take [...]
LOL!? :-/ –> The Princess and The Frog: Controversy Continues with Watermelon Candy « — March 5, 2012
[...] to keep the tradition of racial insensitivity going, The Society Pages reports that Disney recently used Princess Tiana’s image to promote its [...]
Disney’s First Black Princess Promotes Watermelon Candy | Parlour Magazine — March 5, 2012
[...] to Sociological Images, Princess Tiana is paired in a dual candy item with Sleeping Beauty, who boasts her own flavor, [...]
Anonymous — March 5, 2012
yeah and Mulan is cat flavored and Pocahontas is alcohol, and jasmine is felafel.
[Bits and Pieces] A Disney princess, Chick-fil-A petition and other food news from the web, 3.5.12 « Ashlee Eats — March 5, 2012
[...] black princess from The Princess and the Frog? In case you forgot, you can find her on packages of watermelon-flavored candy. Not into the fruit flavor? Try the vanilla-flavored pack featuring Sleeping Beauty. This smells [...]
Disney Princess Tiana Appears On Watermelon Candy Package, Is It Racist? — March 5, 2012
[...] Read more at Sociological Images. [...]
Disney’s Black Princess Sells Watermelon Candy | — March 5, 2012
[...] to keep the tradition of racial insensitivity going, the Society Pages reports that Disney recently used Princess Tiana’s image to promote its [...]
Disney Places First Black Princess on Watermelon Candy Packet | img7.us — March 6, 2012
[...] Sociological Images, who initial pennyless a story, wrote, “In light of [the] history, as good as a ongoing racism, a product next — a Valentine’s Day candy that pairs dual Disney princesses — is rather, let’s say, insensitive. The White Cinderella impression decorates a vanilla flavored side; a Black Tiana impression decorates a watermelon flavored side. Just… wow.” [...]
NiceLady — March 6, 2012
Both kind of ridiculous but with all the other things there are to be outraged about, watermelon flavoured candy didn't make the list
>_< — March 6, 2012
...can I please point out you originally put Cinderella, when in fact Aurora is sleeping beauty?
The assigned princesses seem like something that started out as a bad joke that just happened to make it to final printing. It's happened before, it's most likely ignorance rather than hate.
Disney’s Black Princess Sells Watermelon Candy — March 6, 2012
[...] to keep the tradition of racial insensitivity going, the Society Pages reports that Disney recently used Princess Tiana’s image to promote its [...]
Disney’s Black Princess Sells Watermelon Candy | My Blog — March 6, 2012
[...] to keep a tradition of secular insensitivity going, the Society Pages reports that Disney recently used Princess Tiana’s picture to foster a [...]
The weekend is nigh. | The Nanigans — March 7, 2012
[...] DISNEY’S LATEST D’OH! Oh hey look, it’s the Song Of The South for the new millenium. [...]
Another Racist Disney Move | A Beautiful Mess — March 7, 2012
[...] Sociological Images “The First Black Disney Princess Loves Watermelon“ Share this:TwitterFacebookStumbleUponLinkedInEmailPrintLike this:LikeBe the first to like [...]
Anonymous — March 7, 2012
So the fact that when I see all those watermelons on the White House lawn my first thought is "those will be a really good defense against zombies" (Plants vs Zombies) means that I'm not racist but a huge nerd.
1st Black Disney Princess loves watermelon « omar209 — March 7, 2012
[...] 1st Black Disney Princess loves watermelon [...]
Rattyone — March 7, 2012
If you are not a person of color, and what society considers, a minority, you will never understand the comments, the pictures and all the other deragatory things that goes with being of a person of color. Disney has always painted a negative view or picture of African Americans. In the very old pics of Afr. Amn you see a very dark person eating watermelon, also look at Disney's very old cartoons and see how African Americans are depicted. Even the current Disney TV shows. How many African Americans do you see on these shows? Maybe one per every 3 shows. I am not surprised at Disney, I do not accept it, but not surprised, based on their history of racism. My friend went into a Disney store at Disney World and brought home a metal plate that was posted on the wall of the store. He asked what was it? The sales people didn't know, possibly teenagers, they told him he could have it. It is a pic of a very dark person with racist comments on the plate.
Rashidi Ramanovich — March 14, 2012
The PC police back in full force. Let's ban everything because someone finds it offensive. One day we will be eating out of colourless bags with a non-threatening black arial font.
Vikior — March 14, 2012
I thought it was rather funny. It's not like it was fried chicken flavor. And any self-respecting black man would laugh at that joke. I know, because I have black friends, and we can trade jokes like that. Can't you people?
JASON CASEY IN OHIO...BLACKMAN — March 25, 2012
Ok folks going to share my feelings on it. I thought we were past all this "this is racist and that is racist" crap. Why get up in arms over stuff like this when this is actually a diversion from true issues wrong with this country. Is this image racist? Maybe, if you let it affect you as such. Hey guess what I'm black and I like Watermelon....so what its a food. I eat food, along with Chicken too. So what? Why don't we worry about not only the state of our culture as black people, but the state of America as Americans as well. Think I have had enough of this crap. Focusing on these small things instead of tackling the big issues. Is Racism dead? Of course not. Will it ever go away? Maybe if we live in the Star Trek World. So why waist time trying to knock down a wall with paper and words.
Anonymous — April 2, 2012
It's Russians & Ukrainians who love watermelon....yet white people to whom I tell this don't believe me, think I'm joking....
Hey — May 2, 2012
hey hi hello yo
“Mas quem lavará? Quem cozinhará?”: As Princesas Disney como trabalhadoras e subalternas. | Capitalismo em desencanto — May 6, 2013
[...] anos, somaram-se a essas críticas de matriz feminista também análises acerca dos modelos raciais presentes nesses [...]
“Mas quem lavará? Quem cozinhará?”: As Princesas Disney como trabalhadoras e subalternas. | Foguetes Contra o Infinito — May 11, 2013
[...] anos, somaram-se a essas críticas de matriz feminista também análises acerca dos modelos raciais presentes nesses [...]
Juan Tejeda — May 27, 2013
I found this the other day: http://www.funnyandjokes.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/obama-kidnap-plot.jpg same type of imagery. Really sad seeing this in 2013...
itzmurda — June 8, 2013
I was with a black friend and a white friend and we were eating watermelon and the black guy wouldn't eat any. I asked him to eat some and he said he'd never had any before. He finally got a piece, ate it and didn't say anything about how remarkable it was or how he can't believe he hadn't tried it before now. Leading me to believe, this was in fact not the first time he ever ate watermelon.
With that being said, this article is pathetic. There are people dying in the world, and making up racism is what this author spends her time and efforts on. And she's got a PhD? Wow, Our future is going to be pretty bleek.
KIZIL MASCHERATO — April 7, 2015
Nice all niggers like watermelon
mark — April 25, 2015
...