For the last week of December, we’re re-posting some of our favorite posts from 2011.
————————
In this hilarious two minute video, twin toddlers practice having a conversation. They don’t really know words, but they know HOW to do it. They’ve figured out how to sound sure of themselves, how to sound inquisitive, how to gesticulate, how to aim their efforts at a second person, and how to take turns. They’ve learned, in other words, the rules of talking to another person, even before they’ve learned how to talk. A fun example of socialization.
For more really great examples of children learning to act like grown ups, see our posts on the baby worshipper, the baby preacher, the baby rapper, and the baby Beyonce. Via Blame it on the Voices.
Lisa Wade, PhD is an Associate Professor at Tulane University. She is the author of American Hookup, a book about college sexual culture; a textbook about gender; and a forthcoming introductory text: Terrible Magnificent Sociology. You can follow her on Twitter and Instagram.
Comments 53
:D — April 11, 2011
That's horrible. Why are the parents forcing their own languages, dialects, and beliefs on their children?
They should be able to decide on their own which language they want to learn.
Estella — April 11, 2011
Bizarrely, the first association I have watching this is with the Sims, in which games the Sim people (of all ages) speak in nonsense syllables. It's quite amusing, in any case.
Maryclare Flores — April 11, 2011
: ] Hello! Love the site! Anyway... I have a twin sister and we used to communicate using a "ta ta ta" as the basis of our language. I'm sure they are speaking in this manner to mimic societally acceptable speech patterns, but due to the fact that identical twins share brain waves, I have to believe they know what they are talking about! Would you care to expand on this?
Here are some interesting thoughts! http://www.parentsconnect.com/questions/twins_have_own_language.jhtml
http://multiples.about.com/od/twintoddlers/a/twintalk.htm <-- This is more along the lines of what you are referring to!
Scott — April 11, 2011
So, I think this is a great example of a point where two children who are just beginning to acquire language are communicating entirely in suprasegmentals (parts of communication that do not have discrete semantic content).
I think what would be really interesting to see would be children raised in a Mandarin speaking household and note the difference in inflection. Where these children have adopted conversational intonation to their babbles (to the point where you could reasonably write things like "da da da da da? da da da DA!"), the intonation in Mandarin is part of the word itself, and you could expect that children in Beijing might do this with specific differences based on their language and culture.
Maryclare — April 11, 2011
Whoa.. is there anyway to delete my comment? My full name is there.
Also, it is slightly offensive that you choose to use the phrasing "psychic connection" when I am referring to brain waves, (which exist.. it's a fact). Now, whether identical twins share this, I'm not sure. I chose to comment so that I could share perspective and learn. I am not a credible source nor should I be scrutinized, but, rather, politely corrected or respectfully explained to. When I write a dissertation, I'll be sure to share all my statistics and data, but for now, I simply want to learn.
Here is a source: http://www.psych.umn.edu/psylabs/mtfs/special.htm
-- for my consideration of Monozygotic Twins sharing brain waves.
I appreciate your response and your idea about Mandarin babies will most likely turn out to be expected, but that does not mean they don't understand the babble based off of body language or the understanding of attempted speech.
I would just advise you to be a little more understanding and kind next time! : ]
Casey — April 11, 2011
first thing I thought when I watched the video: "what terrifying little monsters."
Jennifer — April 11, 2011
I've watched this several times and I would bet money it's not real. The movements and mannerisms just aren't right for babies that age.
And since I've convinced myself the video is fake, the babies now scare me like they do Casey! I'm reminded of what I heard recently about that movie "Mars Needs Moms"...apparently people have reported feeling weird about the movie but not knowing why; turns out it's because the CGs are just a little TOO realistic and people are subconsciously creeped out.
Chorda — April 11, 2011
It's fascinating how children can recognize the expected forms before having the skill to utilize them. This sort of mock conversation seems like it's most common when children are being raised together and are very close in age, like with twins. That's when I've seen it as apparent as it is in this video, at any rate. Have there been any studies of pre-verbal mock conversation?
The video reminds me quite a bit of when my four year old neighbor "wrote me a letter", which consisted entirely of scribbles. The scribbles were very carefully following the lines of the notebook paper, though, and had breaks in them to approximate word length. She couldn't even reproduce a letter A yet, but had seen enough writing to know what it was supposed to look like.
videokilledthe — April 11, 2011
I'm surprised that everyone seems to think this is funny rather than sad. If what these babies are doing is spontaneously (more or less) imitating interactions they have witnessed, they must have been exposed to a lot of rather vehement arguing. I know that these days everyone assumes that families argue a lot, but it seems sad that even at a young age children would have been exposed to so much fighting that they would start to imitate it.
JGH2 — April 12, 2011
I like that each of them is only wearing one sock. I wonder if they did that themselves. :D
rhea d — April 12, 2011
That conversation is definitely about socks.
Sarah — April 12, 2011
This is pretty much exactly what goes on at meetings at my workplace. Except for hours, with grown ups. :P
Suedohnim — April 13, 2011
It's definitely about the socks. Between the 2 of them, they have on 3 different socks. They seem to find that laugh worthy. I thought it was cool because it wasn't a bunch of random da da das.
editrix — April 14, 2011
This is a a hilarious translation. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ynq68aR6MWs
Anyone who's worked in a tech startup will have a good laugh.
Coolred38 — April 18, 2011
Having raised 5 children of my own with each around 2 years apart, I can say with confidence that toddlers this age are extremely vocal with each other. They definitely have "conversations" that result in action. For instance, my 3 year old would babble something to my 1 year old who would pay complete attention, then on cue both of them would head over to the toy box and get a toy. Almost as if the older one said, you wanna go play with toys, and away they went. Hard to describe but I am sure those babies are talking to each other and using completely normal toddler actions and sounds. At least from the perspective of a mother of 5.
Steve Bennett — December 27, 2011
Just for your info, in psychodevelopmental terms, this is called canonic babbling. The children are able to initiate conversations with inflection as well as gesticulations (apparently), but are not yet able to form distinct words or syllables. Very, very cute.
Babies Learn How to Have a Conversation » Sociological Images | Baby Images — December 27, 2011
[...] here: Babies Learn How to Have a Conversation » Sociological Images Posted in al, all, Am, an, and, are, at, baby, Be, By, Child, children, for, grow, hare, hip, i, [...]
Andman Salrew — July 30, 2012
I'm surprised that no one I've seen in the comments thus far has mentioned idioglossia. That's what this video is usually used as an example for. The fact that these two are twins is important. At this point in their life, they've probably almost never been away from each other, and the "babblings" they're having are likely more than them mimicking Mommy and Daddy. Children are capable, at exceedingly young ages, of attaching meaning to sounds, and considering these children likely grew up in identical environments, there is likely considerable overlap between their associations of sound and meaning, making a rudimentary language possible, even for these babies.
Briana Gladhill — September 21, 2012
This depicts an early stage of socialization; obviously they are young, but I feel like you can kind of sense a development of basic human conversation. They respond to each others babbling, and it is often experienced, between humans, the talking over of one another
Additional Links from “What is Culture” Unit. | Introduction to Cultural Anthropology — September 22, 2014
[…] babies having a conversation: http://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2011/12/27/babies-learn-how-to-have-a-conversation/ […]